Good COP, Bad COP?

You may remember our guest blogger Nadia Jogee and her post a few weeks ago prior to the landmark COP26 summit.  Nadia is a PhD student at the University of Edinburgh and is a coral reef ecologist, who has had the opportunity to spend three months working with us here at Dynamic Earth as our Discovering the Deep Intern.  Nadia was also lucky enough to attend COP26 in Glasgow recently and has written this week's blog about what she experienced while there...

"I was so pleased to be asked to represent The International Coral Reef Society at COP26, but, once I said 'yes' to going, I quickly realised I didn’t actually know much about what happens at COP meetings. In fact, from talking to friends and family it seemed like no one knew. So several Google searches and rabbit holes later I was much more informed… yet still, I didn’t really know what to expect."

A young lady standing beneath a large model of Planet Earth at COP26, as if she is holding it above her head

"Usually when I attend academic conferences, i arrive on the first day and spend time milling about chatting with a cup of tea & biscuit in hand! Not at COP. The first day I felt an adrenaline rush that no other conference has ever given me. The venue felt like being in a very large, and very busy airport, but where everyone felt guilty about taking their flight. Thousands of people were rushing to be places, whilst many people had seemingly given up and were watching conference events on their laptops in the corridors. I felt like a very small cog in a very large machine and at that point, I felt like I was going to have very little to offer COP26. 

This overwhelming sense of being out of my depth quickly dissipated when I started talking to people. Everyone I encountered was warm, bright and, most importantly, keen to hear about coral reefs and our campaign to save them. I had wonderful conversations with everyone from fellow PhD students from the USA, to indigenous peoples from Panama, to Stewart Maginnis, IUCN’s Global Director of the Nature-based Solutions Group. 

I attended several talks about nature-based solutions, the concept where we utilise what we know about nature and use it to tackle environmental issues. For example, marine ecosystems such as kelp forests and seagrass meadows are great at storing carbon, and provide breeding grounds for many commercially important species, such as crabs and fish. This ability of marine ecosystems to store carbon is called ‘blue carbon’ and COP26 did really feel like a 'Blue' COP. It was clear from the talks I attended and the chats that I had that blue carbon was on many people’s minds – even the food hall had an animated video about it on loop. It was wonderful to see the ocean front and centre."

Group of men and women discussing Climate Change at COP26

"I did wonder however whether our plan of targeting people at ocean related events was the most effective way of lobbying to get our message across. Were we simply preaching to the choir? I certainly saw some very inspirational talks from advocates for the ocean, such as the charismatic Peter Thomson, the UN’s Secretary General's Special Envoy for the Ocean, and Prof. Rashid Sumaila, a professor of ocean and fisheries economics at the University of British Columbia. This made me feel really positive that we were going to achieve our goal of limiting global warming to 1.5 °C and save coral reefs. Therefore, the final outcome of COP26 was a real shock and my heart broke, especially for the small island states, whom I saw fighting to save their nations, not just from disaster, but in some cases total eradication. Many parts of countries like the Maldives, whose highest point is only 2.4m above sea level, will disappear underwater with our current targets. 

Two weeks later and I’m able to reflect more on my experience. I can safely say that attending COP26 was not only a pleasure but great learning experience. Although many positive steps were taken (the creation of a new 500, 000 sq km marine reserve off the west coast of South America for one!) it is unlikely that the pledges made will limit global warming to 1.5 °C - hopefully 2 °C, but likely more... The stark reality is that for coral reefs this will have a profoundly damaging effect. We will no doubt see reefs change dramatically over the coming decades. 

What I will say though, is that whilst there will no doubt be change, what that change looks like still remains largely unknown. We will lose a lot of coral cover, yes, but what replaces it and what species might thrive in the future is still up for some debate. Should we give up? Should we stop trying to save our beloved reefs? NO! We should continue to fight for the ecosystems we love and depend on. 

I certainly think it is worth investing all we can in protecting and restoring habitats despite the unknown future. We should continue trying to build a picture of what future reefs might look like so we are well equipped to respond. We should also invest in science based decisions and further research into methods of protection, because we don’t know what might unlock the door to a brighter future. 

So, after attending COP26, am I more clued up on what happens at COP than I was before? Maybe. I certainly have a better sense of what 99% of people at COP do, but it’s the 1% behind closed doors doing the negotiating that really matter, and I think for those who want to protect the planet the challenge now is to make sure our message crosses that threshold."

2 young ladies standing under a scale model of Planet Earth and a green leafy sign saying COP26

25 Nov 2021


24/03/2022 06:19:06

Thank you for the information, Your information is very helpful for us

Post a comment

Please correct the following:
Latest Comments
By dinosaur game at 24 Mar 2020, 10:29 AM on Fabulous Fossil February!

By dinossauro desenho at 24 Mar 2020, 10:29 AM on Dino's Dynamos Turns 20!

By amaal sara at 18 Feb 2021, 03:14 AM on Celebrate Green Week at Dynamic Earth!

By Jamshed at 4 Mar 2021, 18:53 PM on Celebrate Green Week at Dynamic Earth!

By Umberto Massimino at 28 Apr 2021, 15:36 PM on Explore the Outdoors!

Tom Powell